Key takeaways
- The ICJ is due to rule on whether Myanmar bears state responsibility for genocide against the Rohingya in 2017.
- The court's treatment of genocidal intent, including the 2007 only reasonable inference standard, could shape later cases involving counter-insurgency defences.
- The ruling addresses the Myanmar state, not Min Aung Hlaing personally, while ASEAN engagement with his government continues.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the United Nations' principal judicial organ, is due to deliver its judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar at 10 a.m. on Thursday, 19 November, at the Peace Palace in The Hague, the court announced. The court will decide whether Myanmar bears state responsibility under the 1948 Genocide Convention for its military's 2017 campaign against the Rohingya, a largely Muslim minority from Rakhine State. It may also rule on other obligations under the Convention.
Reuters described the case as closely watched and as the court's first substantive ruling in more than a decade on alleged violations of the Convention. The Guardian and Justice Info report that the ICJ has never before found a state responsible for genocide. No ruling had been issued by 17 November, and every outcome discussed here is a possibility. Hasina Khatun, 34, lost her husband and brother in the Inn Din massacre. She lives in a bamboo and plastic shelter measuring nine by 12 feet in Cox's Bazar, Bangladesh, home to about 1.2 million Rohingya refugees, Reuters reported. "We have been waiting for a long time for the verdict," she told Reuters. "We hope it will bring us justice and pave the way for our return home."
A judgment on a state, not on individuals
The ICJ settles disputes between states. Reuters stresses that it should not be confused with the International Criminal Court (ICC), which prosecutes individuals for crimes including war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide, and that ICJ rulings are final. The distinction matters. Ratko Mladić, whose conviction for genocide over Srebrenica came from the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in 2017 and was confirmed on appeal in 2021, answered for his own acts as a commander. The ICJ is asked something different: whether a state, through its armed forces, breached its treaty obligations.
The Convention defines genocide as acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such. Reuters lists five qualifying acts, including killing members of the group and creating conditions calculated to destroy it. Genocide is harder to prove than war crimes because it requires evidence of specific intent. Intent can be shown by statements or orders, or inferred from a pattern of conduct. The Gambia, a predominantly Muslim country, filed the case in November 2019, according to the International Court of Justice. It asks the court to order reparations and the safe return of refugees, Reuters reported. Myanmar denies genocide. Myanmar describes its operations as a legitimate counter-insurgency campaign against the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), an armed group.
From the 2017 offensive to the Peace Palace
The Hindu reported that on 25 August 2017 ARSA mounted coordinated attacks on 30 police posts and an army base in Rakhine. The military then launched what it called "clearance operations". Reuters reported that more than 730,000 Rohingya were driven into Bangladesh, with refugees describing killings, mass rape and the burning of villages. A UN fact-finding mission concluded that the campaign included "genocidal acts", Reuters reported.
The procedure ran for seven years, according to The Hindu. Emergency hearings took place in December 2019, with Aung San Suu Kyi, then Myanmar's Union Minister for Foreign Affairs, representing the country as its Agent, according to the ICJ record. In January 2020 the court ordered Myanmar to take all measures within its power to prevent acts within the scope of Article II of the Genocide Convention and to preserve evidence of alleged genocidal acts, according to the court's order. In July 2022 it rejected Myanmar's preliminary objections and found that it had jurisdiction under Article IX of the Genocide Convention. Merits hearings ran from 12 to 29 January 2026. The Gambia appointed Navi Pillay, a former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and 2026 Nobel Peace Prize winner, as ad hoc judge. Myanmar chose the German scholar Claus Kreß, according to the ICJ. EUobserver notes that ad hoc judges owe the same duty of independence and impartiality as other judges. Eleven states, including Canada, France, Germany and the United Kingdom, intervened under Article 63 of the Court's Statute.
Observers are reading: how the 2007 "only reasonable inference" test meets Myanmar's counter-insurgency defence, and what each side of the standards debate argues.
Become an Observer, it's free. Get full access to all Crisis.Zone analysis, briefings and breaking coverage.
Gaza, UN fact-finding and the limits of parallels
South Africa filed its case against Israel at the ICJ in 2023, accusing it of genocide in Gaza. Israel denies this and says it targeted Hamas militants. Reuters reported that a final ruling in that case is not expected before 2029. Reuters also relayed the view of Melanie O'Brien, of the University of Western Australia, that the Myanmar case has echoes of the Israel proceedings, particularly over arguments that military operations were legitimate responses to attacks by armed groups. Priya Pillai of the Asia Justice Coalition said: "This case will certainly impact other genocide cases." Michael Becker, a former ICJ legal officer quoted in Malay Mail, said the court's handling of intent could matter when states invoke military or counterterrorism operations.
The caveats are explicit. EUobserver wrote that the Myanmar judgment "will not decide that case, nor should its outcome be prejudged". A Malay Mail contributor wrote that relevance is not equivalence, and that each case "must be determined on its own facts and evidence".
Reuters said lawyers will watch two evidentiary questions. One is how much weight the court gives UN inquiries that found genocidal intent in Myanmar and Gaza. The other is whether it looks beyond mass killing to crimes against women and children, as The Gambia and several intervening states urged. Crisis.Zone reported in October that a UN commission said Israel was continuing "genocidal acts" in Gaza during the ceasefire, which Israel rejected. As that report noted, the commission is an investigative body, not a court, and its findings are not a binding judgment. Reuters reported that Myanmar and Israel both dispute the legal significance of such findings. Antonia Mulvey, founder of Legal Action Worldwide, which represents hundreds of Rohingya survivors, told The Guardian she is cautiously optimistic. She pointed to a pattern of conduct across villages and said the treatment of rape and sexual violence will be a key part of the judgment.
Observers are reading: why a ruling addressed to the Myanmar state may not move ASEAN capitals, and where Singapore's chair year and Thailand's 2028 turn fit.
Become an Observer, it's free. Get full access to all Crisis.Zone analysis, briefings and breaking coverage.
Observers are reading: the three outcomes the court could reach, the enforcement gap, and what ACLED and Human Rights Watch say about conditions that no judgment alone resolves.
Become an Observer, it's free. Get full access to all Crisis.Zone analysis, briefings and breaking coverage.
Three things to watch after the judgment
The court's answer will not be known until it speaks, and three variables will decide how far it travels. The first is the treatment of intent: whether the 2007 formula is applied as written, or whether a counter-insurgency aim is treated as an explanation that can coexist with genocidal intent. The second is the evidence the judges rely on, including UN fact-finding and the sexual violence and harm to children that The Gambia and the interveners urged them to weigh. The third is not legal at all. It is whether governments in the region adjust their dealings with Myanmar's government after a ruling that, by design, does not name individuals.
For the Rohingya awaiting the outcome, the stakes are put in plainer terms. Hasina Khatun told Reuters: "We want to return to Myanmar with dignity, security, citizenship, and our full rights." A 25-year-old Rohingya activist in Yangon, speaking anonymously to AFP, said he is waiting to see the outcome of "the judgement for everything we have been experiencing for generations." Whatever the court says on Thursday, it will be speaking to the state, and the question is who listens.
Become an Observer (it's free) to unlock direct links to all sources used in this article.
We believe you deserve to verify everything we write. That's why we meticulously document every source.
