Key takeaways
- Ryabkov called NATO-style guarantees for Ukraine unacceptable, a day after Kushner said he thought Moscow was comfortable with Article 5.
- Ryabkov said guarantees could be discussed once Kyiv accepts the no-NATO demand as irrevocable; Trump says guarantees follow a deal.
- No guarantee framework or timetable was announced; Putin warned Russia would treat European troops in postwar Ukraine as legitimate targets.
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on Friday that even a formula for Ukraine's "quasi-membership" of NATO is "unacceptable" to Moscow. Reuters, citing the Russian news agency Interfax, reported his remarks. They came a day after US envoy Jared Kushner said he thought Russia had become comfortable with the idea that any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5. That is the collective-defence clause of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO).
Ryabkov tied guarantees to a condition. He said Ukraine should "recognize the irrevocable nature of our demand that this state must not join NATO". The issue of guarantees could then be discussed "in one way or another". Nothing in the record shows that any party has agreed to Article 5-style protection for Ukraine.
Two accounts, one day apart
Kushner spoke on Thursday in Berlin after a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing, a group of governments backing Ukraine. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky attended, along with leaders or representatives of Germany, France and the United Kingdom. Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff had shuttled from Abu Dhabi to Moscow and Dublin earlier this month.
"I think we've gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept, where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5," Kushner said, according to The Hill. He gave a belief, not a Russian commitment. He also acknowledged "a lot of skepticism and disbelief".
Asked on Friday whether Article 5-style guarantees would be acceptable, Ryabkov said Moscow discusses security guarantees "first and foremost in terms of ensuring the security of our own country". Interfax carried the remarks, as quoted by Reuters, and Tass reported them in similar terms.
At the White House the same day, US President Donald Trump was asked about the gap. "Look, our side put out things because it's also a public relations war," he said. "I don't want to talk about security guarantees because we got to get a deal first." Trump did not say what guarantees Washington would offer, and no timetable was announced.
Overnight on Thursday into Friday, Russia launched an attack that Zelensky described as one of the largest on Ukraine and that the Institute for the Study of War (ISW), a US research group, called the largest Russian strike of November. Zelensky said on Friday that eight people had been killed and nearly 30 injured. By Friday evening, Kyiv's mayor had raised the toll in the capital to seven, and the Kyiv Independent reported a nationwide toll of at least nine.
Observers are reading: how Moscow's redefinition of "guarantee", Trump's deal-first sequencing and Europe's exposed force fit together, with labelled analysis.
Become an Observer, it's free. Get full access to all Crisis.Zone analysis, briefings and breaking coverage.
What to watch
Four markers will show whether Moscow's position moves. First, whether a delegation from Britain, Germany and France travels to Moscow. As of Saturday morning, no date had been announced; Ryabkov said on Friday that Moscow was still waiting for a reply to its invitation. Second, whether Moscow's list of conditions changes at the next round. Third, whether Washington puts any guarantee text on paper. Fourth, the early-January US target for a deal that the Financial Times reported, citing four people briefed on the discussions. Europe has said it would be represented by Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland plus the EU institutions, but Russia has not publicly accepted that line-up and has invited only Britain, France and Germany to Moscow. These judgments are time-bound and may change with Moscow's next statement.
Become an Observer (it's free) to unlock direct links to all sources used in this article.
We believe you deserve to verify everything we write. That's why we meticulously document every source.
