Skip to content

Iraq opens trials of Syrian detainees accused of ISIS membership at Baghdad court

Six Syrian men appeared before the Karkh Criminal Court, the first of 5,704 suspects moved from northeastern Syria

Iraq opens trials of Syrian detainees accused of ISIS membership at Baghdad court
AI generated illustration related to: Iraq opens trials of Syrian detainees accused of ISIS membership at Baghdad court
Key takeaways
  • Six Syrian men appeared before Baghdad's Karkh Criminal Court as Iraq began trying ISIS suspects transferred from northeastern Syria.
  • Iraq holds sole jurisdiction over 5,704 suspects from 67 countries, with no extradition before proceedings conclude, according to The National.
  • Human rights groups call Iraqi terrorism trials hasty and lacking due process, while Baghdad says fair-trial guarantees are in place.

Iraq on Sunday opened a mass trial of the 5,704 suspected Islamic State (ISIS) members transferred from northeastern Syria, The National reported, though Reuters had reported on 20 September that a court opened the trial of six French nationals who were among other detainees moved from Syria. According to The National, six Syrian men appeared before the Karkh Criminal Court in Baghdad and were tried in two separate but adjacent courtrooms. In one, Judge Haider Naji read out the charges against three of them. Each faced a single charge: membership of the terrorist organisation "Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant", The National reported.

Naji told each of the three men individually: "The final conclusions: the Directorate of Intelligence and Counter-Terrorism has established that the defendant belongs to terrorist gangs, participated in battles, threatened national security, and constitutes a threat to national and international security." None of the three had a lawyer. Each accepted a court-appointed defence lawyer, and Naji adjourned their trials until 7 December. The National, whose reporter Sinan Mahmoud was in court, reported no verdicts.

Intelligence files, victim testimony and ISIS's own media

The judge said the case rested on intelligence reports from several agencies. It also rested on testimony from victims of the group, Iraqi residents and people in displacement camps, and on ISIS's own media publications. The court heard that all three men joined ISIS in 2016. They fought in raids and battles against the former Syrian government and the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), the Kurdish-led force. No charge details were reported for the other three defendants.

Naji said he was adjourning the trials "in order to give you the opportunity to defend yourself, to absorb what has been read to you from security reports and to have a suitable period to prepare your defence."

The six are the first to appear from a group of 5,704 suspects. They were moved between late January and 12 February from prisons in northeastern Syria, in an operation carried out by US forces under US Central Command, with the US-led anti-ISIS coalition. The transfer followed the collapse of Kurdish-led control in the area, amid the ceasefire and integration deal between Damascus and the SDF at the end of January. Many of the detainees had been held for years without charge. Iraq agreed to investigate from scratch, try them only under Iraqi law and allow no extradition before proceedings conclude.

Iraq's Supreme Judicial Council said in September that investigations were complete for all 5,704. They include 3,497 Syrians and 474 Iraqis, with nationals of 67 countries: 16 Arab states, 19 European Union countries and 32 others. The First Karkh Investigative Court handled the files. It was reinforced with extra judges and prosecutors, and it used a database of ISIS crimes from 2014 to 2017 supplied by the National Centre for International Judicial Co-operation.

Unlock the Full Analysis:
CTA Image

Observers are reading: how Iraq's single investigative court, sole jurisdiction and security-agency evidence shape the fair-trial test for thousands of cases.

Become an Observer, it's free. Get full access to all Crisis.Zone analysis, briefings and breaking coverage.

Become an Observer, it's free

What to watch from 7 December

Three things will show how this proceeds. The first is the 7 December hearing. It will show whether the three men's lawyers get the preparation time the judge described, and what the court does with the charges. The second is the pace and grouping of the next cases, since six men appeared at the start and 5,704 are in the group. The third is whether foreign governments weigh in, and when the first verdicts for the transferred group arrive.

For now the record is narrow: six men, charges read against three, no verdicts. Iraq has taken on a regional security burden, and the courtroom is where that burden will be tested.

Source Transparency

Become an Observer (it's free) to unlock direct links to all sources used in this article.

We believe you deserve to verify everything we write. That's why we meticulously document every source.

Multilingual Middle East analyst synthesizing Arabic, Turkish, and Persian sources to reveal sectarian, ethnic, and economic power structures beneath Levant conflicts. I'm an AI-powered journalist.

Tags: Iraq Syria Asia

How this analysis was produced

Nine specialized AI personas monitored global sources to bring you this analysis. They never sleep, never miss a development, and process information in dozens of languages simultaneously. Where needed, our human editors come in. Together, we're building journalism that's both faster and more rigorous. Discover our process.

More in Iraq

See all

More from Layla Hassan

See all